A Book A Week

Countless cold cases remain consigned to an eternal lack of resolution, their evidence fading into the mists of time due to insufficient resources. For every high-profile instance of a perpetrator being held accountable, numerous other mysteries remain in perpetual limbo. Laurah Norton has long harbored a deep fascination with these unsolved cases, haunted by the lingering "what ifs" and unanswered questions. Yet, as a writing professor, her interest remained merely a personal preoccupation. This changed dramatically when the case of two twins was cracked open by the groundbreaking methods of forensic genealogy. Similar technology had been pivotal in unveiling the identity of the notorious Golden State Killer, prompting Norton to launch a podcast specifically dedicated to unresolved cases. The success of this podcast not only validated Norton's enduring passion but also directed much-needed attention and resources toward forgotten and neglected cold cases.

Lay Them to Rest features Norton's comprehensive exploration of the forensic methodologies in solving murder cases. The book takes readers on a historical journey through the profession's evolution, all while shedding light on modern-day technologies. Concurrently, it follows the efforts to unravel the identity of "Ina" Jane Doe, a case dating back to the early 1990s. The discovery of a dismembered, unidentified female head in an Illinois state park presented an enduring mystery, leaving investigators stumped due to the scarcity of evidence for identification. Norton collaborates with seasoned forensic anthropologist Dr. Amy Michael, leveraging Michael's extensive experience and network of committed forensic scientists to focus on cracking this long-standing case. This gripping narrative gives readers an inside view of the scientific processes, speculations, and serendipitous moments that form the foundation for identifying the nameless victim in this compelling cold case.

The determination behind solving the "Ina" Jane Doe case fascinated me. Norton’s detailed narrative unveils the intricate steps essential to cracking this mystery, emphasizing the evolving technology and relentless pursuit of answers. However, the scarcity of resources poses a significant barrier in examining every case, leaving many forgotten by time. This stark reality resonated deeply while reading. The absence of a unified system to consolidate critical data like dental records and DNA adds to the challenge, forcing investigators to rely heavily on luck and tireless dedication to unravel such cases.

Though Lay Them to Rest admirably debunks the myths surrounding forensic investigations perpetuated by media, the book sometimes delves excessively into technical minutiae. While the meticulous examination of "Ina" Jane Doe's teeth, for example, yielded critical breakthroughs, the exhaustive detail occasionally disrupted the book’s pacing, causing a sporadic imbalance between the urgency of the mystery and the in-depth forensic descriptions. Despite this, Norton's insightful writing sheds light on a widely misunderstood field, providing a valuable understanding of the realities of forensic work and ultimately aiding in solving a decade-old cold case. The book remains an engrossing and enlightening read.

For more information, visit the author's website, Amazon, and Goodreads. 

(2023, 86)

In recent years, my fascination with crime fiction has evolved into a deep interest in the realm of true crime. The narratives that unfold within these works often feel like they belong to the world of fiction, yet the knowledge that these events actually happened adds a unique layer of intrigue. Last year, I was captivated by a true-crime memoir and retrospective penned by Paul Holes, an investigator whose involvement in numerous high-profile cases over the decades was truly engrossing. Beyond his captivating insights into high-profile cases, it was his introspective exploration of the toll these investigations took on his personal life that resonated the most. They served as a powerful reminder that every headline-worthy story has a profound impact on the lives of real individuals. 

It's this very idea, the resilience of people navigating the aftermath of unthinkable tragedy, that lies at the heart of investigative journalist Susan Hendricks' new book, Down the Hill. When given the chance to receive a copy of this book from her publisher, I eagerly embraced it. Drawing on her extensive background in broadcast journalism and her personal intrigue with the case, Hendricks delves into the narrative of a tragic double homicide that sent shockwaves through the tight-knit community of Delphi, Indiana.

"Their family always said I love you in place of goodbye. Every single time. Just in case something happened."

Tragedy often strikes unexpectedly. While you witness it on the news daily, you never anticipate it happening to someone like you. Especially not in a safe haven like your own neighborhood. Delphi, Indiana embodied this sense of security, a tight-knit community where everyone knew one another. It was the kind of place where families felt at ease raising their children. When Abby Williams and Libby German planned a day of adventure on their day off from school, exploring the well-trodden hiking trails near Monon High Bridge, it seemed like a simple, harmless decision. The concerns were minimal. Libby's grandmother only reminded her to take a coat for the changing weather. As Libby's sister dropped them off at the trailhead, it was just another ordinary day. Little did they know that it would mark the final time they would ever see Abby and Libby alive.

"There are many dates in a lifetime that you're going to remember: The dates your children are born. The date you're married. The date you buy a first house. The date Abby and Libby went missing."

What began as a missing person case, characterized by concern rather than panic, took a tragic turn as the bodies of Abby and Libby were discovered on the north bank of Deer Creek, approximately a mile from where they were last seen. Susan Hendricks, then a reporter for CNN and HLN, was among the media personnel covering the incident. In the initial stages of reporting, Hendricks was struck by the limited information provided by investigators. The primary piece of evidence revolved around the visual and audio fragments of a disturbing interaction the girls had with an unfamiliar individual shortly before their disappearance—a disconcerting encounter that Libby had captured on her cellphone. This sole lead would become the cornerstone of the case for the years to come. The chilling audio of the man instructing the girls to go "down the hill" reverberated in the thoughts of those dedicated to uncovering the truth behind this devastating event.

Down the Hill sees Susan Hendricks take a detailed look into a crime that captured the nation's attention. The profound tragedy that befell such innocent individuals begs the question of how such horror could occur. Hendricks masterfully portrays the moments leading to the crime and the exhaustive pursuit of justice. The narrative spans from early 2017 to today, with a suspect now arrested and awaiting trial. While the ongoing nature of the case prevents a conclusive ending, Hendricks's storytelling is marked by meticulous care. Her personal connection with the victims' families during her investigation adds a distinct dimension to this true crime account. Their resilience, facing each day with courage while ensuring their loved ones are never forgotten, deeply moved me. Amid their tireless efforts to bring awareness and sustain a years-long investigation, they not only honored their daughters' memory but also offered support to other families grappling with similar tragedies. In the face of an incomprehensibly senseless crime of inhumanity, the families maintained their own humanity, ultimately inspiring the world through their unyielding strength.

For more information visit the author's website, Amazon, and Goodreads. 

(2023, 58)

It has been a while since a thriller indeed thrilled me. As a suspense lover, I am constantly seeking the next book that will keep me on my toes. A downside to reading as many books in the genre as I do is that I can usually spot the twist or end well before reaching the climax. Reading a mystery or thriller is still fun, but not knowing how everything will finish brings an extra layer of suspense and satisfaction. It was with high hopes that I accepted a copy of Robyn Harding's latest The Drowning Woman from her publisher. The premise drew me in, but the twists ultimately turned me into a fan. 

Lee is about as close to rock bottom as she could possibly be. After opening her restaurant, she was living her dream. COVID arrived, crushing Lee's business, romance, and any chance at a real future. Now she travels around with only her beat-up Toyota and a meager amount of clothes. There's really no way things could get any worse. One morning, as Lee lies on the Seattle beach, letting time pass by, she takes notice of a sobbing woman. The lady seems hysterical. Lee gazes on as the woman thrusts herself into the frigid ocean. She's clearly decided to drown herself. Rushing to action, Lee dives into the water after her, hauling the woman back to the safety of the shore. 

The woman Lee rescued is anything but grateful for the good deed. Her name is Hazel, and she's downright furious with Lee. Hazel explains that she's been part of an abusive relationship, and she felt that death was her only way out. Now Lee has robbed her of that escape. After they've parted ways, Lee is certain she's seen the last of Hazel. But the next day, Hazel returns. The pair begin to bond over their collective misfortunes, creating a friendship that shouldn't be. Then one day Hazel makes a bizarre request. She's come up with another way to leave her husband, and she wants Lee to help her disappear. 

As I began reading The Drowning Woman, I felt a bit off-kilter. I didn't understand how Harding's story about a down-on-her-luck, homeless woman could possibly turn into a thriller. Even as the initial setup about the drowning woman unfolded, teeing up the domestic suspense to come, I didn't think this book would end up wowing me. Then, in a masterful stroke of plotting that completely swept the rug out from under me, Harding changed the POV of the book. Learning about the events that I'd just read from a different perspective completely blew my mind. Suddenly the true nature of this twisted story was disclosed, and the reveals didn't stop coming. I easily breezed through the latter half of the novel, blindsided by each new revelation. Yes, logical thinking derails a bit of the story, but I didn't care. I was completely sucked into this book and couldn't put it down. The plot does center around a consensual nonconsensual relationship that gets pretty dark, so be warned of the potential triggers there. Still, if you're searching for a thriller that will keep you guessing, go ahead and pick up The Drowning Woman. You won't regret it. 

For more information visit the author's website, Amazon, and Goodreads. 

(2023, 35)

What's your go-to genre? My tastes have evolved and varied, but I always return to crime fiction. There's just something about following a character through the process of investigative discovery that I find eternally appealing. It should come as no surprise then that I happily accepted a copy of The Wheel of the Doll by Jonathan Ames from his publisher. This follow-up to his novel A Man Named Doll promised to be an "...irreverent and inventive mystery...", so I knew I had to give it a read. I hadn't read the first book in the series, but I wasn't about to let that stop me from diving right in. 

When we meet our hero, he is physically and emotionally scarred from his last case. All things considered, though, he's ready to hop back into the proverbial saddle. A man named Happy Doll probably doesn't have any other choice but to be optimistic. He's a private investigator who relies on independent cases for his livelihood, so he's willing to listen to the young woman who shows up at his door with an offer for a new investigation. He's not prepared, however, for the way this case will force him to reckon with his past. 

The woman is named Mary DeAngelo, and she's looking for her mother Ines Candle. Happy instantly recognizes the mother's name as an ex-lover of his. The last time the couple was together, she barely survived an attempt at suicide. Happy is saddened to learn that her life didn't get better after that. Mary has been estranged from Ines for a while, but recently received a Facebook message that alleges to be from her. Mary's mysterious husband puts up the funds to pay Happy to find Ines. As he embarks on finding her, he's left with more questions than answers. Old wounds will reopen and new ones are sure to follow. 

The Wheel of the Doll sees Jonathan Ames write a hardboiled private investigator novel that blends echoes of the genre's past while blazing a trail into the future. This is a small, intimate story that takes full advantage of developing the characters and the mystery with laser-like precision. Reading about this down-on-his-luck investigator reminded me of some of the great noir novels, especially as the entire book is set in the shadows of Los Angeles. Ames hints at some of the events that happened in the first novel, but this story is self-contained enough that I never felt lost. There's a sparseness to the work that makes it compulsively readable. I was hooked from beginning to end, unable to pull myself from the pages. The Wheel of the Doll is a novel that knows exactly what kind of story it is trying to tell, and Ames deftly executes it to its fullest potential. 

For more information visit the author's website, Amazon, and Goodreads. 

(2022, 50)