In her debut novel, The Witch's Orchard, Archer Sullivan introduced readers to private detective Annie Gore. The story pulled Annie back to her hometown deep in Appalachia, where a missing persons case forced her to confront the traumas of her own past. I was so taken by Sullivan's ability to craft a compelling mystery steeped in atmosphere that I vowed to read whatever she came up with next. Fortunately for me, her next novel, Brimstone Hollow, has arrived. It's a sequel that returns to Annie and the world Sullivan so vividly created in her debut. This time around, Sullivan builds upon everything that worked so well before, leveling things up in almost every possible way.
Since the events of the first novel, Annie Gore has built quite the reputation as a reliable private eye. Her work often draws her away from her home base in Louisville and back into the Appalachian Mountains she thought she'd escaped years ago, but Annie has made peace with the path life has put her on. By now, she's confident she's seen just about everything.
That confidence is tested when she's hired to investigate the death of one of the state's last snake-handling preachers. His estranged daughter, who, much like Annie, fled Appalachia more than twenty years ago, is shocked to learn that her father was fatally bitten by one of the snakes he handled. Even stranger, he was buried within twenty-four hours of his death, and she wasn't notified until after the fact. She's convinced there's more to his death than a tragic accident and hires Annie to find out what really happened.
Maybe it's the bizarre circumstances that pique her interest, or maybe Annie recognizes something of herself in this woman who also fought to escape the place she once called home. Either way, she takes the case. The deeper Annie digs into the preacher's death and the town around it, the more questions surface. And someone seems dead set on making sure she never finds the answers.
Brimstone Hollow might be my favorite mystery novel I've read so far this year. Archer Sullivan has written a story that transports you to this off-the-beaten-path town, immersing you in its atmosphere, traditions, and people. The characters who inhabit it feel authentic, each navigating their own challenges while becoming an important piece of the larger mystery. And at the center of it all is Annie, a flawed protagonist who's simply trying to do her best, uncover the truth, and bring justice where she can.
Sullivan fills the story with the kind of things I find impossible to resist in a mystery. Venomous snakes, religious turmoil, family drama, dangerous chases...this book has it all. And the mystery? Boy, it kept me on the edge of my seat for the entire novel. I listened to the audiobook this time around, and Emily Pike Stewart's narration perfectly brought Annie and her world to life. The Witch's Orchard made me eager to read whatever Sullivan wrote next. Brimstone Hollow has me convinced Annie Gore is a character I'll happily follow wherever her next case takes her. In the meantime, do yourself a favor and read these first two books in quick succession. I don't think you'll be disappointed.
For more information, visit the author's website, Amazon, and Goodreads.
(2026, 63)

